Test 21: The Book of Revelation's Testimony

Phase 6: Present Application

⚠️ Note: This content is currently in review and available for public examination.

The Central Question Before Us

What does the book of Revelation teach about God's commandments and their relevance in the last days? Does Revelation support the view that the commandments (including the Sabbath) are obsolete, or that they remain binding and central to end-time faithfulness?

The book of Revelation, as the final book of Scripture, provides the capstone testimony on this question. It describes end-time events and the characteristics of God's faithful people. If the moral law were abolished, we would expect Revelation to reflect this. If the law remains binding, Revelation should affirm it.

The evidence must be examined.

⚖️ Preliminary Matter: Revelation's Unique Position

The applicable legal principle:

UK — Final Word Doctrine:

The final statement in a series of documents carries particular weight as the conclusive position.

*US — Morton v. Mancari, 417 U.S. 535 (1974):

"Where there is no clear intention otherwise, a specific statute will not be controlled or nullified by a general one."
Application:
Revelation is the final book of the biblical canon. It was written:
After all other New Testament books
After decades of church development
As the climactic revelation of end-time events
If the church had moved away from Sabbath observance, if the commandments were understood as abolished, Revelation would reflect this mature, post-apostolic understanding. What Revelation teaches about the commandments is therefore highly significant.

The Two Positions Under Examination
Position A (Commandments Obsolete): The commandments are part of the old covenant that passed away. Revelation's references to "commandments" refer to general Christian obedience or the "law of Christ," not the Ten Commandments or the Sabbath specifically. Position B (Commandments Central to End-Time Faith): Revelation explicitly identifies God's end-time people as "keeping the commandments of God." The Ten Commandments, including the Sabbath, remain binding and are central to final faithfulness.
PART 1: THE COMMANDMENTS IN REVELATION

Section 1.1: Revelation 12:17 — The Dragon's War Against Commandment-Keepers

Revelation 12:17 — "And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ."
The applicable legal principle:

UK — Plain Meaning Rule — R v Judge of the City of London Court [1892]:

Angel	Message	Reference
First	"Fear God, and give glory to him... worship him that made heaven, and earth"	14:6-7
Second	"Babylon is fallen"	14:8
Third	Warning against worshipping the beast and receiving his mark	14:9-11

Words must be given their ordinary, plain meaning.
Analysis: Who is the dragon?
Revelation 12:9 — "That old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan."
Who is the woman? The woman represents God's people/church throughout history (Revelation 12:1-6 traces her from Christ's birth through persecution). Who is the remnant? The final generation of God's faithful people — those at the end of time. What characterises the remnant?
Two identifying marks:
They "keep the commandments of God"
They "have the testimony of Jesus Christ"
The significance:

Satan's final war targets those who "keep the commandments of God." This is not incidental — it is the defining characteristic that identifies them and makes them Satan's targets.
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Identifying Distinctive Marks:

When someone is identified by specific characteristics, those characteristics are essential to their identity.
Question for Position A: If the commandments are obsolete, why does Satan make war specifically against commandment-keepers? Why would this characteristic identify God's end-time people? Finding: Revelation 12:17 identifies God's remnant people by their commandment-keeping. This presupposes the commandments remain binding and distinguishing in the last days.
Section 1.2: Revelation 14:12 — The Patience of the Saints

Revelation 14:12 — "Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Repetition for Emphasis:

When a point is repeated, it is emphasised as particularly important.
Context: The Three Angels' Messages
Revelation 14:6-12 contains the "three angels' messages" — God's final warning to the world:

Angel Message Reference
First "Fear God, and give glory to him... worship him that made heaven, and earth" 14:6-7
Second "Babylon is fallen" 14:8
Third Warning against worshipping the beast and receiving his mark 14:9-11
Immediately following these warnings, verse 12 identifies the faithful response:
"Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus."
The significance:
In the context of:
A call to worship the Creator (echoing the fourth commandment)
A warning against false worship (the mark of the beast)
The most solemn warning in Scripture (eternal consequences)
The saints are identified as commandment-keepers.
Finding: Revelation 14:12 reinforces that commandment-keeping characterises God's faithful people in the last days. The commandments are not obsolete — they are central to end-time loyalty.
Section 1.3: The Greek Phrase — "Commandments of God"
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Technical Terminology:

When a phrase has a consistent technical meaning, that meaning governs.
The Greek phrase: tas entolas tou theou (τὰς ἐντολὰς τοῦ θεοῦ)

entolas (ἐντολάς) — commandments
tou theou (τοῦ θεοῦ) — of God

Reference	Text	Context
Matthew 15:3	"Why do ye also transgress the commandment of God by your tradition?"	Jesus defending God's law
Matthew 22:36-40	"The great commandment in the law"	Jesus quoting Deuteronomy 6:5 and Leviticus 19:18
Mark 7:8-9	"Laying aside the commandment of God... ye reject the commandment of God"	Jesus condemning those who nullify God's commands
1 John 5:2-3	"We love the children of God, when we love God, and keep his commandments. For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments"	John defining love as commandment-keeping

How is this phrase used elsewhere?
Reference Text Context
Matthew 15:3 "Why do ye also transgress the commandment of God by your tradition?" Jesus defending God's law
Matthew 22:36-40 "The great commandment in the law" Jesus quoting Deuteronomy 6:5 and Leviticus 19:18
Mark 7:8-9 "Laying aside the commandment of God... ye reject the commandment of God" Jesus condemning those who nullify God's commands
1 John 5:2-3 "We love the children of God, when we love God, and keep his commandments. For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments" John defining love as commandment-keeping
The phrase "commandments of God" consistently refers to God's moral law — the divine commands given by God Himself, particularly the Ten Commandments. Finding: The phrase "commandments of God" in Revelation 12:17 and 14:12 uses established biblical terminology for the Ten Commandments.
Section 1.4: Revelation 22:14 — Access to the Tree of Life

Revelation 22:14 — "Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Conditionality:

When a blessing is conditioned on a requirement, that requirement is essential for receiving the blessing.
Analysis: The blessing: Right to the tree of life; entrance into the New Jerusalem The condition: "Do his commandments" The implication: Commandment-keeping is connected to eternal life and entrance into God's kingdom. Position A's problem:
If the commandments are obsolete, why is doing them the condition for:
The blessing of Revelation 22:14?
Access to the tree of life?
Entrance into the Holy City?
The applicable legal principle:

UK — Luke v IRC [1963] — Presumption Against Absurdity:

Revelation 14:7	Exodus 20:11 (Fourth Commandment)
"worship him that made"	"made heaven and earth"
"heaven"	"heaven"
"earth"	"earth"
"the sea"	"the sea"
(fountains of waters)	"and all that in them is"

Inside the City	Outside the City
Those who "do his commandments"	"Whoremongers" (7th Commandment violators)
	"Murderers" (6th Commandment violators)
	"Idolaters" (1st/2nd Commandment violators)
	"Liars" (9th Commandment violators)

Interpretations producing absurd results must be rejected.

It would be absurd to condition eternal blessing on keeping obsolete commandments. The very conditionality demonstrates the commandments' continuing validity.
Finding: Revelation 22:14 conditions entrance to the New Jerusalem on doing God's commandments. This presupposes their continuing validity.
PART 2: THE SABBATH IN REVELATION

Section 2.1: Revelation 14:7 — Worship the Creator

Revelation 14:7 — "Fear God, and give glory to him; for the hour of his judgment is come: and worship him that made heaven, and earth, and the sea, and the fountains of waters."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Allusion and Reference:

When language clearly echoes another text, the connection is intentional and significant.
Comparison with the Fourth Commandment:
Revelation 14:7 Exodus 20:11 (Fourth Commandment)
"worship him that made" "made heaven and earth"
"heaven" "heaven"
"earth" "earth"
"the sea" "the sea"
(fountains of waters) "and all that in them is"
The first angel's message directly echoes the language of the fourth commandment — the Sabbath commandment, which calls for worship of the Creator.
Exodus 20:8-11 — "Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy... For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it."
The significance:
In the end-time call to worship, God uses the language of the Sabbath commandment. The call to worship the Creator echoes the very commandment that memorialises creation and identifies the true God.
Finding: Revelation 14:7's call to worship the Creator deliberately echoes the fourth commandment. The Sabbath's significance is embedded in God's final message.
Section 2.2: Revelation 11:19 — The Ark of the Covenant in Heaven

Revelation 11:19 — "And the temple of God was opened in heaven, and there was seen in his temple the ark of his testament: and there were lightnings, and voices, and thunderings, and an earthquake, and great hail."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Symbolic Significance:

When an object appears in a vision, its known significance illuminates the vision's meaning.
What is "the ark of his testament"?
The ark of the covenant contained:
The two tablets of the Ten Commandments (Deuteronomy 10:1-5)
Aaron's rod that budded (Numbers 17:10)
A pot of manna (Exodus 16:33-34; Hebrews 9:4)
The primary content was the Ten Commandments — called "the testimony" (Exodus 25:16, 21).
The significance:
At the climax of Revelation 11 — the sounding of the seventh trumpet, the announcement of God's kingdom — the heavenly temple is opened and the ark containing the Ten Commandments is revealed.
Why show the ark?
The ark's appearance connects the end-time judgment with the standard of judgment: the Ten Commandments. God reveals that His law remains the standard — it is preserved in the Most Holy Place of the heavenly sanctuary.
Finding: The ark of the testimony (containing the Ten Commandments) is revealed in heaven at a climactic moment. This demonstrates the commandments' continuing relevance and heavenly preservation.
Section 2.3: Revelation 1:10 — "The Lord's Day" Revisited
As examined in Test 20, "the Lord's day" (Revelation 1:10) does not demonstrably refer to Sunday. The phrase more plausibly refers to:
The seventh-day Sabbath — the day Christ claimed as "Lord of" (Mark 2:28)
The eschatological Day of the Lord — fitting for apocalyptic prophecy
The phrase provides no evidence for Sunday observance replacing the Sabbath.
PART 3: THE CONTRAST — THOSE WHO REJECT THE COMMANDMENTS

Section 3.1: Revelation 22:14-15 — Inside vs. Outside

Revelation 22:14-15 — "Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city. For without are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Contrast for Clarity:

When opposites are presented, each illuminates the other.
The contrast:
Inside the City Outside the City
Those who "do his commandments" "Whoremongers" (7th Commandment violators)
"Murderers" (6th Commandment violators)
"Idolaters" (1st/2nd Commandment violators)
"Liars" (9th Commandment violators)
The significance:
Those excluded from the city are described by their violations of the Ten Commandments:
Murder — 6th Commandment
Sexual immorality — 7th Commandment
Idolatry — 1st/2nd Commandments
Lying — 9th Commandment
If the commandments are obsolete, how can violating them result in exclusion from eternal life?
Finding: The contrast between commandment-keepers (inside) and commandment-breakers (outside) demonstrates the commandments' decisive, eternal significance.
Section 3.2: Revelation 21:8 — The Second Death

Revelation 21:8 — "But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Penalty Implies Prohibition:

When a penalty is attached to conduct, that conduct is prohibited.
Analysis:
The "lake of fire" is the destiny of:
Murderers — violators of the 6th Commandment
Whoremongers (sexually immoral) — violators of the 7th Commandment
Idolaters — violators of the 1st/2nd Commandments
Liars — violators of the 9th Commandment
The applicable legal principle:

UK — Luke v IRC [1963] — Presumption Against Absurdity:

True Worship	False Worship
"Worship him that made heaven, and earth" (14:7)	"Worship the beast and his image" (14:9)
"Worship God" (19:10; 22:9)	Worship of the dragon and beast (13:4)
The seal of God (7:2-3)	The mark of the beast (13:16-17)

Interpretations producing absurd results must be rejected.

If the commandments are obsolete:
Murder would not be wrong
Adultery would not be wrong
Idolatry would not be wrong
Lying would not be wrong
Yet Revelation assigns eternal penalty to these acts. The commandments clearly remain in force.
Finding: Revelation's eternal penalties for commandment-breaking prove the commandments' continuing validity.
PART 4: THE WORSHIP CONFLICT IN REVELATION

Section 4.1: True Worship vs. False Worship
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Central Theme Identification:

Repeated emphasis on a subject indicates its centrality to the document's purpose.
Revelation's central conflict is over WORSHIP:
True Worship False Worship
"Worship him that made heaven, and earth" (14:7) "Worship the beast and his image" (14:9)
"Worship God" (19:10; 22:9) Worship of the dragon and beast (13:4)
The seal of God (7:2-3) The mark of the beast (13:16-17)
The issue in the end-time is not merely religious profession but HOW and WHOM one worships.
Section 4.2: The Mark vs. The Seal

Revelation 7:2-3 — "I saw another angel... having the seal of the living God: and he cried... saying, Hurt not the earth... till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads."

Revelation 14:9 — "If any man worship the beast and his image, and receive his mark in his forehead, or in his hand..."
The applicable legal principle:
UK — Identifying Marks:

When opposing parties are identified by marks, those marks represent their essential allegiance.
The seal of God:
Placed on the forehead (the mind — indicating willing allegiance)
Identifies "the servants of our God"
Contrasts with the mark of the beast
What might the seal of God be?
A seal contains three elements:
Name of the authority
Title of the authority
Territory of the authority
The fourth commandment uniquely contains all three:

"The seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD [name] thy God [title]... For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is [territory]" (Exodus 20:10-11)

No other commandment identifies God by name, title, and domain. The Sabbath is the "seal" commandment — the sign of the Creator's authority.

Ezekiel 20:12, 20 — "I gave them my sabbaths, to be a sign between me and them, that they might know that I am the LORD that sanctify them... hallow my sabbaths; and they shall be a sign between me and you, that ye may know that I am the LORD your God."
Finding: The Sabbath, as the sign of God's creative authority, is positioned to be "the seal of God" in the final conflict over worship.
PART 5: FINAL ASSESSMENT

The Evidence Weighed
The applicable legal principle:

UK — Re H (Minors) [1996]:

Issue	Position A	Position B
Rev 12:17	Cannot explain commandments identifying remnant	Commandments characterise God's end-time people
Rev 14:12	Cannot explain commandments defining saints' patience	Commandment-keeping central to faithfulness
Rev 22:14	Cannot explain commandments as condition for eternal life	Commandments required for entrance to city
Rev 14:7	Cannot explain fourth commandment language	Creator worship echoes Sabbath commandment
Rev 11:19	Cannot explain ark (containing commandments) in heaven	Commandments preserved in heavenly sanctuary
Rev 21:8; 22:15	Cannot explain penalties for breaking "obsolete" commands	Commandment-breaking excludes from eternal life

The balance of probability — more likely than not.
Summary:
Issue Position A Position B
Rev 12:17 Cannot explain commandments identifying remnant Commandments characterise God's end-time people
Rev 14:12 Cannot explain commandments defining saints' patience Commandment-keeping central to faithfulness
Rev 22:14 Cannot explain commandments as condition for eternal life Commandments required for entrance to city
Rev 14:7 Cannot explain fourth commandment language Creator worship echoes Sabbath commandment
Rev 11:19 Cannot explain ark (containing commandments) in heaven Commandments preserved in heavenly sanctuary
Rev 21:8; 22:15 Cannot explain penalties for breaking "obsolete" commands Commandment-breaking excludes from eternal life
Finding on standard of proof: Position B is established by clear and convincing evidence. Revelation consistently presents commandment-keeping as characteristic of God's faithful people and essential for eternal life.
The Clear Statement Test
The applicable legal principle:

UK — Morgan Grenfell [2002] — Clear Statement Rule:

Issue	Finding
Revelation 12:17	Commandment-keeping identifies the remnant
Revelation 14:12	Commandment-keeping characterises the patient saints
Revelation 22:14	Commandment-keeping conditions eternal life access
Revelation 14:7	Creator worship echoes fourth commandment
Revelation 11:19	Ark with commandments revealed in heavenly sanctuary
Revelation 21:8; 22:15	Commandment-breaking results in second death
Seal vs. Mark	The worship conflict has commandment implications

Significant changes require clear statement.
Does Revelation state the commandments are abolished?
No. Revelation:
Identifies the remnant as commandment-keepers (12:17)
Identifies the saints as commandment-keepers (14:12)
Conditions entrance to the city on doing the commandments (22:14)
Excludes commandment-breakers from eternal life (21:8; 22:15)
Echoes the fourth commandment in the first angel's message (14:7)
Reveals the ark (containing the commandments) in heaven (11:19)
Not one verse in Revelation suggests the commandments are obsolete. Every relevant passage affirms their continuing, decisive significance.

# CONCLUSION AND VERDICT

Summary of Findings

Issue Finding
Revelation 12:17 Commandment-keeping identifies the remnant
Revelation 14:12 Commandment-keeping characterises the patient saints
Revelation 22:14 Commandment-keeping conditions eternal life access
Revelation 14:7 Creator worship echoes fourth commandment
Revelation 11:19 Ark with commandments revealed in heavenly sanctuary
Revelation 21:8; 22:15 Commandment-breaking results in second death
Seal vs. Mark The worship conflict has commandment implications

The Verdict
The book of Revelation — the final word of Scripture — unequivocally affirms the continuing validity of God's commandments:
The remnant is identified by commandment-keeping (12:17)
The saints are characterised by commandment-keeping (14:12)
Eternal life is conditioned on commandment-keeping (22:14)
The Creator-worship call echoes the fourth commandment (14:7)
Commandment-breaking excludes from eternal life (21:8; 22:15)
The commandments are not obsolete. They are the distinguishing mark of God's faithful people in the final conflict. The Sabbath, as the sign of the Creator and the seal of God's authority, holds particular significance in the end-time worship conflict.

Revelation 14:12 — "Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus."

Key Texts Reference

Topic Text
Remnant identified Revelation 12:17
Saints' patience Revelation 14:12
Condition for eternal life Revelation 22:14
Creator worship call Revelation 14:7
Ark in heaven Revelation 11:19
Excluded from city Revelation 21:8; 22:15
Seal of God Revelation 7:2-3
Mark of the beast Revelation 14:9-11

Greek Terms Reference

Greek Transliteration Pronunciation Meaning
ἐντολή entolē "en-toh-LAY" commandment
τὰς ἐντολὰς τοῦ θεοῦ tas entolas tou theou "tahs en-toh-LAHS too theh-OO" the commandments of God
σφραγίς sphragis "sfrah-GEES" seal
χάραγμα charagma "KHAH-rahg-mah" mark
κιβωτός kibōtos "kee-boh-TOS" ark

Legal Authorities Cited

United Kingdom

Authority Citation Principle
R v Judge of the City of London Court [1892] 1 QB 273 Plain Meaning Rule
Luke v IRC [1963] AC 557 Presumption Against Absurdity
Morgan Grenfell v Special Commissioner [2002] UKHL 21 Clear Statement Rule
Re H (Minors) [1996] AC 563 Standard of Proof

United States

Authority Citation Principle
Morton v. Mancari 417 U.S. 535 (1974) Specific over General
Gregory v. Ashcroft* 501 U.S. 452 (1991) Clear Statement Rule
---
← Previous: Test 20 Next: Test 22 →

Topic	Text
Remnant identified	Revelation 12:17
Saints' patience	Revelation 14:12
Condition for eternal life	Revelation 22:14
Creator worship call	Revelation 14:7
Ark in heaven	Revelation 11:19
Excluded from city	Revelation 21:8; 22:15
Seal of God	Revelation 7:2-3
Mark of the beast	Revelation 14:9-11

Greek	Transliteration	Pronunciation	Meaning
ἐντολή	entolē	"en-toh-LAY"	commandment
τὰς ἐντολὰς τοῦ θεοῦ	tas entolas tou theou	"tahs en-toh-LAHS too theh-OO"	the commandments of God
σφραγίς	sphragis	"sfrah-GEES"	seal
χάραγμα	charagma	"KHAH-rahg-mah"	mark
κιβωτός	kibōtos	"kee-boh-TOS"	ark

Authority	Citation	Principle
R v Judge of the City of London Court	[1892] 1 QB 273	Plain Meaning Rule
Luke v IRC	[1963] AC 557	Presumption Against Absurdity
Morgan Grenfell v Special Commissioner	[2002] UKHL 21	Clear Statement Rule
Re H (Minors)	[1996] AC 563	Standard of Proof

Authority	Citation	Principle
Morton v. Mancari	417 U.S. 535 (1974)	Specific over General
Gregory v. Ashcroft*	501 U.S. 452 (1991)	Clear Statement Rule

Test 21: The Book of Revelation's Testimony

The Central Question Before Us

⚖️ Preliminary Matter: Revelation's Unique Position

The Two Positions Under Examination

Section 1.1: Revelation 12:17 — The Dragon's War Against Commandment-Keepers

Section 1.2: Revelation 14:12 — The Patience of the Saints

Section 1.3: The Greek Phrase — "Commandments of God"

Section 1.4: Revelation 22:14 — Access to the Tree of Life

Section 2.1: Revelation 14:7 — Worship the Creator

Section 2.2: Revelation 11:19 — The Ark of the Covenant in Heaven

Section 2.3: Revelation 1:10 — "The Lord's Day" Revisited

Section 3.1: Revelation 22:14-15 — Inside vs. Outside

Section 3.2: Revelation 21:8 — The Second Death

Section 4.1: True Worship vs. False Worship

Section 4.2: The Mark vs. The Seal

The Evidence Weighed

The Clear Statement Test

Summary of Findings

The Verdict

Key Texts Reference

Greek Terms Reference

Legal Authorities Cited

United Kingdom

United States

Visitor Stats